Corporate Accountability International
Search  |  Site Map


Download this page as a pdf 
Back to Nominees
Cast your vote now 

More about Toyota
*Lobbying against fuel economy
*Green rhetoric, greenhouse reality

*Corporate snapshot
*Take action
 

Protesters at Santa Monica Toyota, call on the corporation to drop its opposition to California’s clean car bill.

Most of us now understand that pollution from cars causes global warming. So, we also know that driving cleaner cars – like Toyota’s low-emission, 48 miles-per-gallon (mpg) Prius hybrid – means less global warming pollution.

Unfortunately, the overall truth about Toyota is, well, inconvenient. The carbon footprint of Toyota’s overall car fleet remains dinosaur-esque, and their lobbyists are working to kill national legislation that would force them to stop selling their gas guzzlers by 2020.

Toyota’s opposition to the proposed 35 mpg standard has left many of its loyal, green-minded customers feeling surprised and betrayed: “To hear all of a sudden that they’re lobbying against the higher [gas mileage] standards makes me nuts. What are they thinking?” asked Mark Gamba, a Prius-owning Oregonian. [1]

Meanwhile, competitors like Nissan support the new standards.

Lobbying against fuel economy
Toyota is actively lobbying Congress to defeat the proposed measure to increase fuel-efficiency standards to 35 mpg by 2020. The standard would cut more than 200 million metric tons of global warming pollution in 2020 alone. Toyota’s DC lobbying team says its engineers “don’t know how” to meet the standard.[2] Could these be the same engineers that already make cars that get 48 mpg? And the same company that already meets Japan’s more rigorous standards? Toyota’s technological know-how seems not to be the main roadblock here. 

Also, two major auto trade associations of which Toyota is a member – the Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers and the Association of International Automobile Manufacturers – are suing to stop California's new law to reduce global warming pollution.

Finally, Toyota has opposed “clean cars” legislation in multiple states. In addition to requiring that cars emit less pollution, including global warming gases, clean cars legislation requires that a percentage of cars sold within the state be low- or zero-emission vehicles.
 
Green rhetoric, greenhouse reality
Thanks to an aggressive marketing campaign and the widespread familiarity of the Prius, green-minded Americans tend to think of Toyota as a corporate ally in the fight against global warming. Toyota's website warns against the dangers of global warming—calling it “the most serious of the world's environmental issues.” 

In the fall of 2007 Toyota also launched a series of green TV advertisements. USA Today wrote the following description: “[the ads feature] a mud-hut Prius being assembled out of twigs, earth and grass by a group of rugged campers. Against a moody mountain backdrop, the Prius slowly disintegrates back into the land, while an announcer says, ‘Can a car company grow in harmony with the environment? Why not? At Toyota, we're not only working toward cars with zero emissions.’”

All told, Toyota spent nearly $3.1 billion worldwide in 2006 (nearly $2 billion in the US) marketing its products and overall image.[3] On top of that, Toyota and its trade associations spent at least $7.7 million lobbying elected officials in Washington, DC.[4]   

Corporate snapshot
Toyota Motor Corp., founded in 1933, is doing just fine in these tough economic times.   They’re in a pitched battle with GM to be the #1 car-seller in the world, each selling more than eight million cars in Fiscal Year 2007.   In the first quarter of FY07, the Japanese auto giant sold more cars than anyone, surpassing GM for the first time. In 2007’s third quarter, they posted record revenues and profits and Toyota projects a FY 2007 profit of nearly $16 billion. Overall, Toyota is the world’s largest automaker by net worth, revenue and profits.[5]

To date, Toyota has sold more than 1 million fuel-saving hybrid vehicles worldwide and accounts for 78% of hybrid sales in the US.[6] However, hybrid sales only tell a small part of their story: Toyota's current, fleet-wide fuel efficiency is lower today than it was a couple decades ago, thanks to their continued reliance on selling gas guzzlers like their 14 mpg Tundra pickup.[7]

Meanwhile, according to Congressman Ed Markey (MA), "Toyota meets higher fuel-economy standards in Japan than they say we want them to meet here in 13 years [by 2020]. It's almost as if they're not going to make any improvements in 13 years," Markey says.[8]

Take action

Several national and state environmental groups have launched a coordinated campaign to expose and pressure Toyota, including Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC), Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS), League of Conservation Voters (LCV), US PIRG, Environment California, Conservation Law Foundation (CLF), and Friends of the Earth.  The coalition’s “Truth About Toyota” website was launched to coordinate these efforts: http://www.truthabouttoyota.com/facts.html

The site also provides a forum for the public to get involved. 


[1]  Learn, Scott. “Stuck in some green mud.” The Oregonian, October 12, 2007.
[2]  Ibid.
[3]  Advertising Age. “21st Annual Global Marketers: Part 1, Global Ad Spending by Marketer.” Crain Communications Inc. & Ad Age Group, November 19, 2007.  http://adage.com/images/random/globalmarketing2006.pdf
[4]  Toyota Motor Corp & associated subsidiaries spent $3,030,000 in federal lobbying in 2007 as reported by Center for Responsive Politics: http://www.opensecrets.org/lobbyists/clientsum.asp
?txtname=Toyota+Motor+Corp&year=2007
.  The Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers spent $4,672,690 in federal lobbying in 2007 as reported by the Center for Responsive Politics: http://www.opensecrets.org/lobbyists/clientsum.asp
?txtname=Alliance+of+Automobile+Manufacturers&year=2007
.
[5]  Associated Press. “Toyota’s profits boosted by emerging markets.” MSNBC.com, February 5, 2008.  http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/23008016/
[6]  Healey, James R.  “Green groups go after Toyota.” USA Today, October 4, 2007.
[7]  Naughton, Keith. “Toyota’s green problem: Despite the Prius, environmentalists are turning on the carmaker for opposing new gas-mileage laws.” Newsweek, November 19, 2007 issue.
[8]  Healey, James R.  “Green groups go after Toyota.” USA Today, October 4, 2007 Toyota’s current fleet-wide fuel efficiency standard is lower today than twenty years ago.

 

 

 
top